This or That: Skein or Cake? (Winners Get Gems!)

It depends on my energy levels, but I prefer yarn cakes

7 Likes

I Always Leave Them In The Skeins and Pull from the Center, so No Unraveling Necessary! Much Prefer It That Way!

7 Likes

I like to have mine a skein, but if it falls apart, I have to use my yarn winder to make it into a cake! Although, I kinda do like having a cake more, because it’s easier for it to stand :cherry_blossom: :peach:

7 Likes

Well, I’ll leave it in a skein…until it all falls out :joy: then I make it a cake :upside_down_face:

7 Likes

Skein!

6 Likes

well usually I get skeins because my favorite yarn is in skeins, but I prefer yarn cakes.

6 Likes

I always rolled mine into balls until I learned about cakes so I bought a cheap winder and now I cake them unless the skein is too big for my winder.

7 Likes

I would love a skein ( as apparently a cake holds too much tension and can damage yarn if left for two long) BUT PLEASEEEEEEEEE PLEASSEEEEEEEE
MAKE THE YARN TAIL CLOSE TO THE CENTER PLEASE I BEG YOU :folded_hands:t4::folded_hands:t4::folded_hands:t4::folded_hands:t4::folded_hands:t4:

No way I need to perform abdominal surgery everytime I need to use a new yarn :melting_face::melting_face:

7 Likes

I prefer cake (unless it’s a color I really need to use and haven’t caked it yet :joy:)!

7 Likes

I’ve never used a cake, but I want to try! :birthday_cake:
I’m a skein user. :blush:

4 Likes

I usually leave it in a skein until it becomes annoying to unravel, and then I would make it into a cake. I also wait to do so bc a whole skein takes forever to make into a cake :sob:

6 Likes

hmmm i would choose skein prob cuz all my yarn is like that, ive never used a cake before lol

5 Likes

I leave it in a skein, but only because I don’t have a winding machine thing and I’m too lazy to do it by hand. That being said, whenever I’m on the go, I hand wind some yarn around my fingers to take with me in smaller quantities. But that’s neither cake nor skein really.

6 Likes

Omg cake all the way. So tired of yarn barf in the middle of skeins. I’m hoping Ribblr yarn is different bc I hate taking the time to make yarn into a cake lol. I actually buy a lot of used yarn and it’s often in cakes already, which is great, and when I go to a LYS I ask them to put it in a cake for me since they usually have the super fancy whamodyne electric winders.

5 Likes

I leave in skien till it falls apart.

4 Likes

Luke many others here, skein until it starts falling apart and then I making into a ball. Reminds me of my grandma when yarn winders did not exist. Keeping in skeins allows me to keep the label on it. I don’t have time to do everything I want to do in a day, so I don’t waste time making it into a cake or ball from the beginning lol!

4 Likes

I wind mine into a cake it works so much better to crochet with and it stays in one place so nice :) :) :) :) :) :) :) :) :) :)

3 Likes

Mm imo I like leaving my yarn as a skein, but if it gets tangled I wind it into a cake :growing_heart:

3 Likes

Oooo I pretty much just leave it as a skein because it’s easier to transport in my backpack on the planes. Even when it falls apart, I try to leave it as much in the bundle as possible with the outside wrapped around the center to hold it together.

3 Likes

I roll it into a ball, sadly, as I haven’t managed to purchase a cake winder yet. And when I tried a hack for doing it with a pen and your thumb it didn’t quite turn out like the one in the video!

2 Likes